Carrageenan vs Guar Gum
Side-by-side comparison of safety, regulations, and usage.
Caution E407
Carrageenan
Thickener
From seaweed. Some controversy over gut inflammation. EU approved but under review
USApproved (GRAS)
EUApproved
UKSame as EU pre-Brexit
JapanApproved
Safe E412
Guar Gum
Thickener
Natural thickener from guar beans
USApproved (GRAS)
EUApproved
UKSame as EU pre-Brexit
JapanApproved
| Feature | Carrageenan | Guar Gum |
|---|---|---|
| Safety Rating | Caution | Safe |
| Category | Thickener | Thickener |
| E-Number | E407 | E412 |
| Banned Somewhere? | No | No |
| Controversy | high | low |
| US Status | Approved (GRAS) | Approved (GRAS) |
| EU Status | Approved | Approved |
Quick Verdict
Based on current evidence, Guar Gum appears to be the safer choice with a "Safe" rating compared to Carrageenan's "Caution" rating. However, individual circumstances vary. Always consult healthcare professionals for personalized dietary advice.
More Comparisons
See an error? Report it